Featured Products

Home & Auto Insurance
Home & Auto Insurance

Combining your home and auto policies can benefit you with discounts that help you save and additional coverage options to make your life easier.

Coverage for Your Business
Coverage for Your Business

We're committed to keeping your business protected so you can focus on your day-to-day operations.

Farm Insurance
Farm Insurance

Preserve your livelihood with an agribusiness policy that safeguards your farm and everything on it, from buildings and machinery to crops and livestock.

Classic Car Insurance
Classic Car Insurance

A vehicle as unique as its driver requires more than a basic Auto policy. Make sure your Specialty Auto is protected.

Main Office
Main Office
1150 West 5th Street Marysville, OH 43040
Office: 937-642-2026
Fax: 937-642-1860

Find out what sets us apart from the other guys.

Meet Our Team

Classic Car and Business Insurance in Marysville, OH

Mill Creek Insurance Agency

For nearly 80 years, Mill Creek Insurance has provided residents and businesses with peace of mind knowing their finances and assets are secure. We are a third generation agency specializing in classic and collector car insurance, business and commercial insurance, as well as traditional personal lines. We have established relationships with the nation’s top providers including Motorists Mutual, Celina Mutual, and Wayne Mutual. This gives our agency the edge we need to stay above the competition and provide you with high quality service and products.

Serving Marysville Since 1938

As the oldest agency in Marysville, we have seen this community thrive and grow into what we see today. We are highly involved in the community through local high school sports, our agent Drew Conley sits on the board for the Marysville Historical Society, and Jan Ramge is a member of the Marysville Lions Club.

We truly have a pulse on this area and understand the risks families and business owners face on a daily basis. That is because we take the time to meet with every customer and fully understand their needs and create custom insurance solutions that are free from gaps in coverage.

What you can expect from us

We have a full team of knowledgeable agents who always keep our clients top of mind. We review every policy thoroughly to make sure our customers are receiving the right coverage when it is time to renew. If you are looking to work with an agency that is professional with a hometown feel, call us at 937-642-2026 to learn more. You can also contact us through email or request a quote to get started on a policy

American Modern logo
Celina Insurance Group
CNA Surety Logo
Foremost Insurance logo
Hagerty Insurance logo
Motorists Life Insurance Company
Motorists Mutual Insurance Co.
Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Logo
Progressive Insurance logo
Philadelphia Insurance Logo